It is safe to say that at the moment, WordPress does not have the largest presence in the federal government. By large, Drupal is the preferred CMS in the federal government.
Recently, we spoke at WordCamp DC where we were able to outline some reasons as to why and how we can help WordPress grow throughout the federal government.
First, lets identify some of the problems keeping WordPress less popular. There are three main reasons that Drupal appears to be the popular CMS over WordPress.
Early adoption by government agencies, in particular Whitehouse.gov
Mis-information about WordPress, especially when comparing to Drupal
Lack of extra incentives
WordPress Vs. Drupal
WordPress developers frequently hear a lot of these arguments and concerns about WordPress.
Drupal is more flexible and complex because:“Drupal contains taxonomies, content types, blocks, views, and user/role management”
We hear this a lot, but it’s misleading to say because WordPress also offers the following:
- Custom taxonomies and content post types
- Instead of blocks it has widget areas
- Instead of views… well WordPress does not have something similar but there are plenty of dynamic page builder plugins.
- WordPress has plenty of user and role management plugins such as the members plugin.
Drupal handles large volumes of content much better than WordPress
Often times, this seems like a moot argument. Whenever we hear people arguing about X framework versus Y framework it usually boils down to scalability. But are you ever going to reach those upper limits you are arguing for? And if so, why can’t WordPress handle “large volumes of content”? We developers have seen plenty of sites with thousands of pages and posts.
Drupal can support thousands of pages and thousands of users
So can WordPress! WordPress.com is a single instance of the WordPress Multisite codebase and serves millions of websites and users.Edublogs.org hosts millions of sites on one WordPress Multisite installation with over 3 million users.
Drupal is more secure than WordPress – WordPress is plagued with vulnerabilities
It’s true that over the years, there have a been a number of high profile vulnerabilities, but these vulnerabilities are almost always a result of using a poorly built plugin, or out of date plugin. WordPress itself is very quick to fix any discovered vulnerabilities. So installing free, low quality plugins or just the first plugin you see is not WordPress’s fault.
That’s a managerial decision, and that that needs to change. Same goes for not staying on top of your plugin updates. If you choose not to update your plugins, or you choose to keep a plugin that hasn’t been updated in years, then you take the risk of running something with security vulnerabilities.
Personally I think this is a perspective people have about websites in general. That once you build it the first time, you can just walk away from it and not think about it again and we wish that were the case. But like your cars, you need to maintain it to keep it running smoothly.
WordPress was originally built as a blogging platform
Yes that’s true, but WordPress, just like everything else has grown and changed. WordPress hasn’t been a “blogging” platform for years. Our WordPress engineer Kyle Jennings uses WordPress as an application framework to build user centric web apps.
WordPress goes the extra mile
A lot of these arguments above seem to be related to WordPress’s approach to addressing the same issues that Drupal has addressed,but at the end of the day these discrepancies don’t actually exist. And because WordPress also offers user friendliness and intuitive design, that have in our opinion blown Drupal out of the water, we think the real discrepancies lay with Drupal.
Extra Incentives Supporting WordPress
In 2015, the U.S. Digital Services teamed up with 18f to create an official front-end framework for government websites called U.S. Web Design Standards (USWDS). It is basically Twitter’s Bootstrap but built for the federal government and focuses on accessibility compliances, making it easy and affordable for agencies to build or rebuild their websites.
Our WordPress developer, Kyle Jennings built a WordPress theme named Benjamin with these standards. Benjamin makes extensive use of the awesome WordPress Customizer to provide a ton of flexible and thoughtful settings as well as a live preview of your changes. Here is a quick overview of settings:
- Support for 11 templates + custom post types
- Each template get’s it’s own:
- Sidebar area
- Header settings
- Sidebar setting
- Layout control
- Some pages contain optional and sortable content
- The footer and header are both sortable
- A companion plugin – Franklin provides short code support for all the USWDS visual components, grid column support for editing content, and Digital Search support
So by using Benjamin and Franklin, agencies can quickly and easily spin up their own websites, that are branded with federally ordained style guidelines as well as easily customize their sites to meet their needs at any given time.
In case you missed the top reasons why the federal government is moving to Drupal be sure to read and let us know which content management system you prefer!